
https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/790545/the-coroners-silence-by-terence-keel
Megha Bahl: One of the central threads running through your work is that to reach the truth underlying deaths in custody, we need to look at not just the medical and biological reasons but also the legal, political, and structural conditions of such deaths. Could you elaborate for our readers about your idea of seeing society inside the body and how it can be a means to identify structural racism in the context of deaths in custody?
Terence Keel: The etiology of dying in state custody is much broader than we realize. The process does not start with being arrested or placed in a jail. Law enforcement and the coroner complete a sequence of slow death and dismemberment that is accelerated by policy decisions that deny people food, shelter, jobs, medical care, and that invest in carceral systems. We are living in the wake of a nation that has aggressively eroded the social welfare state since the Reagan administration and under Trump millions of Americans are facing reduced SNAP benefits, evaporating healthcare insurance, and meager unemployment benefits. What do we imagine will happen to these people? Where will they end up if they cannot find care for mental illness, substance abuse issues, or a place to live? The answer is that far too many end up dying in police custody.
Upstream of these policy decisions is a resilient belief that some people in America are unworthy, disposable, and likely to die early because of innate limits within their biology. Those limits are often assumed to be set by Nature/God and once this idea has taken hold the state can do whatever it wants to people without being held responsible for their death. Our underdeveloped ideas about evolution serve the state in this regard. When most of the population believes we only carry nature (or God’s will) in our bodies we lose the ability to see and comprehend the effects of social institutions and policy decisions over our life chances. The interaction between human biology and society is where a great deal of observable change happens within your lifetime. Autopsy records that blame people for their own deaths while in police custody are the most extreme example of our collective ignorance about how the societies we design work back upon us. What makes all of this terrifying is that causes of in-custody death should be obvious, but far too many Americans still believe George Floyd died because of a heart abnormality. Part of this is explained by blatant racism, the hold of conservative beliefs about law and order in the U.S., and the fact that we deny so many people the opportunity to learn how human biology is always being shaped by our environment at many scales.
But I also believe this misunderstanding is the effect of government retreating from the lives of everyday Americans—again the fallout of dismantling the social welfare state. How can you believe government and policy decisions are responsible for the death of George Floyd when you can’t see the state in your everyday lives because it is removing itself from your healthcare, education, job prospects, and ability to find shelter? In that landscape people simply appear free to live or die according to their own decisions. Of course, those decisions are predetermined and constrained by the very policy decisions made by elected officials that place people in free fall, not freedom, and at the edge of living. Surviving under this state of affairs has physiological and epistemological consequences that can be measured, observed, and named in plain language. This is why I wrote The Coroner’s Silence. It is a book about police violence, autopsies, and much more.
Megha Bahl: While discussing suicides in custody you borrow from Durkheim to describe the case of 22-year-old Kalief Browder as anomic suicide. Kalief suffered eight hundred days of solitary confinement at Rikers Island while awaiting trial. As I learned from your work, he was ultimately discharged and released but committed suicide later. “Trauma fragments time in the body,” (p.152) you write. Could you elaborate this thought?
Terence Keel: There is a strange Panglossian myth that surrounds life in America, where we believe we are living in the best of all possible worlds. But when someone takes their life in this country, the myth begins to fall apart. Rates of suicide in the United States are at all time high across all demographics, but especially among men between the ages of 18 and 35. I turned to Durkheim to think about this issue because he was one of the first to see suicide as a structural issue and not merely an innate feature of a person’s psychology. Being embedded within a network of care, respect, and meaning, according to Durkheim, offers protection against the impulse to take one’s life. Durkheim also believed there were two different types of suicide: anomic suicide, where someone takes their life after the social bonds around them fail, and fatalistic suicide, where someone kills themselves as a final expression of agency under life-denying circumstances.
At the age of 15 Kalief Browder was arrested and placed into jail on Rikers Island for allegedly stealing a backpack. He could not afford bail and was forced to wait in jail to see a judge. While inside he was beaten by guards, forced to fight with other inmates, and thrown into solitary confinement for nearly eight hundred days. Charges against Kalief were eventually dropped and he was released from Rikers—but the violence and trauma had taken their toll. Before taking his life Kalief’s story gained attention from the media because it spotlighted the violence of our nation’s jails and our predatory bail system. I think of Kalief’s death as a type of anomic suicide in the sense that he lost a part of himself while inside Rikers because the social life around him was broken. Even though he was seen as free at the time of his death, a part of his mind and body, I believe, was still trapped inside Rikers—can you imagine being a teenager and forced into solitary confinement for two years, all for supposedly stealing a backpack? The trauma of that experience fractured time inside of a body that was technically free but still carried the effects of violent imprisonment, as if it were still happening—and at some level it was. Trauma has a way of trapping parts of ourselves in the moment when our nervous system was forced into fight, flight, or freeze responses. Sometimes that activation never shuts off. There are countless people right now holding trauma from the past after being placed into jail or being threatened by increased police presence in their neighborhoods. Some of those people may take their lives. And the cause of that death will not be some innate defect or pathology; it will be the violence of our criminal legal system. Like in the case of Kalief Browder.
Megha Bahl: I see your work as an illustration of a study where documents are the central ethnographic objects. Relying on the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), you and your team at the UCLA BioCritical Studies Lab obtained one thousand autopsy reports of people killed by the police across the United States. Your analysis of these reports shows how death investigators are unwilling to see the socio-political context of deaths in custody. Could you walk us through the details of your research methodology, the scope and limitations of the methods you adopted and how you dealt with some of these limitations?
Terence Keel: Thank you for framing it that way, because the description of documents as ethnographic objects is exactly right, and it gets at something central to how the BioCritical Studies Lab works.
The methodology grew out of a relationship before it grew out of a protocol. It was an activist and grieving mother — Helen Jones — who taught me how to read an autopsy with the wisdom and experience of impacted communities, and from that we launched the Coroner Report Project, which standardized local wisdom and experience into research questions and a protocol that allowed the lab to critically evaluate any death record. I want to emphasize that sequence. The community knowledge came first; the formal instrument came after. We built a national coding protocol that allowed student researchers to study autopsy reports of individuals who died in custody and answer survey questions coded to that protocol — which lets us identify patterns systematically across records rather than anecdotally.
Our approach is deliberately interdisciplinary. We use data science, critical forensic analysis, public health research, and legal studies to identify patterns in how police-related deaths are investigated, reported, and addressed. The broader evidentiary base is substantial: the team collected and verified a list of more than 32,000 law enforcement–related deaths and reviewed autopsy reports and records over a 20-year period (2000-2020) that allowed us to see the magnitude of the problem. Dying during arrest in America was not a marginal issue but a consistent one that happens daily. In fact, we discovered that in just 20 years American law enforcement killed more than twice the number of people executed in this country dating back to 1608 (roughly 16,000). Dying in custody has become the new capital punishment.
Now, to your question about limitations. Access was a serious constraint, and it was not incidental — it was structural. In our Los Angeles County study, we received only 59 of roughly 300 autopsies from a ten-year period; the rest were held back under security holds placed by the Sheriff’s Department, even though California autopsies and coroner’s reports are public documents. As I said at the time, our ability to do the study was compromised by an inability to access all the records. That incompleteness is a genuine limitation on any claim to statistical representativeness — but it is also, itself, a finding about how local government designs a carceral system able to resist scrutiny. When there are no records, Americans can exist in a Panglossian illusion that assumes the carceral state is necessary, natural, and the best way to deal with people at the margins in our society. Not having records also distorts our understanding of how the carceral state deforms the bodies of the people inside.
What the accessible records revealed was striking: more than half of the people officially classified as dying from causes like cardiac disease, respiratory illness, or flu showed evidence of hematomas, bone fractures, and lacerations. Our interpretive move was to insist that these forms of physical violence contributed to death, thereby casting doubt on any natural death classification.
We addressed the limitations in two ways. First, by grounding interpretation in community partnership and triangulating documents against families’ knowledge and related records. Second, by being clear about the fact that the narrow science-based approach of medical examiners can only go so far in telling the full story about in-custody deaths — and that ours is a critical, structural reading, that helps create a fuller picture precisely because we are measuring that interaction between society and human biology at many different scales. That scale includes everything from the violence of police interactions to the documentation practices of the medical examiner, which too often reconstruct those interactions in ways that favor the state.
Megha Bahl: You describe how these autopsy reports were a “fragmented and imperfect archive,” one fragmented by design. You note how the obscure, detached, and biased language in these reports is intended to erase these victims of police violence from our collective memory. It reminded me of Trouillot’s work Silencing the Past, where he argued how history is selectively silenced by the powers that be. Could you share your experience of sifting through a fragmented archive of racialized deaths and the moments where the attempt of erasure felt most prominent?
Terence Keel: It took reading hundreds of these records with community to understand that the autopsy is not written for the victim, but exists to protect the state. Once you see the autopsy from that perspective everything changes; the redactions, missing organs, incomplete files, and the fact that police can be in the room during the medical autopsy are all a part of how victims are misremembered and the Panglossian myth of law and order is renewed. In the book I explain that when my lab first started requesting records from the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner, they provided us files with virtually no redactions. Things changed after we started publishing reports with our community partners that gained significant media attention because we revealed bias and inconsistencies in the death records. Afterwards, the county retaliated by redacting records that we received. Entire sections of the informant/witness statement report, which describes the circumstances leading up to the death based on interviews with police and bystanders, were blacked out and unreadable. The fact that these sections were hidden from view was especially revealing as they were most incriminating for police, not the medical examiner. The reason the medical examiner would do this is only clear once you understand that there is an alliance between death investigation and the anti-democratic interest of the state. The Black, Latino, and poor white communities I worked with were the first to understand this alliance.
Megha Bahl: Please share with our readers how you see your work as a manifestation of or inspired by Ruha Benjamin’s idea of ‘viral justice’ like the collective legal reform efforts to ensure oversight for custody deaths in Maryland or drawing from members of the impacted community like Helen Jones for your research.
Terence Keel: Name any problem facing our democracy and I assure you there are already community organizations working on the issue—sometimes led by people directly impacted and therefore carry unique wisdom about how to solve that problem. These efforts are likely not to be recognized by legacy news organizations or your social media feed, but that does not make them any less real. I learned this very early working with abolitionist organizations fighting to stop state violence and in-custody death around the country. There are people committed to a just future for all of us because they know what life looks like in the void, or the wake of state violence in all its forms. One of the many things I enjoy about Ruha Benjamin’s work is her ability to see that justice movements have a virality to them, meaning they often inhabit many sites of needing repair simultaneously and exist in a network of contagious exchange—ideas, practices, aspirations—not always obvious. In the book I discuss how I worked with justice advocate Carmen Johnson and Maryland Senator Joanna Benson to write a bill to help stop in-custody death by creating greater transparency. The goal of the bill was to create a civilian led independent investigation of any death inside a detention center or jail within the state. My lab discovered that the first 24 hours were the most lethal stretch of time inside any Maryland carceral facility. This meant these deaths were preventable and having an independent investigation that reviewed the work of state appointed death investigators would help us learn what went wrong and how future tragedies could be avoided. More than forty organizations testified in the Senate and House in support of our bill, including the Maryland Office of the Public Defender, Maryland Alliance for Criminal Justice Reform, Maryland Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services, Maryland Department of Health, and National Bar Association. Family members of the deceased and mothers of sons who were still incarcerated gave chilling testimonies urging lawmakers to find their humanity. This network of government and non-government organizations was truly an example of viral justice, with alliances being among constituents that are not always aligned but were in this moment over this issue. A modified version of our bill was signed into law by Governor Wes Moore, but the experience I believe sent a clear message about what is possible when people come together to create the future everyone deserves.







